Sign Up to our mailing list

The Voice of Canada’s growing pellet sector
  • Video: Heating with Wood Pellets

    Heating with wood pellets is an effective way to help in the fight against climate change.

  • Video: Wood Pellet Association of Canada

    Existing coal plants can be cost-effectively repurposed to use wood pellet fuel to help the environment and reduce air pollution.

  • Pellets

    Made from renewable forest byproducts and unmerchantable material, wood pellets from Canada provide a renewable, sustainable fuel source for generations to enjoy. | Read More

  • Sustainable

    Only 9% of the world’s forest are certified. Over 42% of them are in Canada, making it an ideal source for sustainable wood pellets. | Read More

  • Renewable

    WPAC members rely on sawmill waste and forest harvest residuals for the bulk of their fibre supply, allowing 100% resource use. | Read More

  • Fossil Fuel Alternative

    Whether on their own or co-fired with coal, wood pellets provide a lower carbon footprint and renewable energy source. | Read More

  • Innovative

    WPAC continues to support R&D in key wood pellet areas like safety, efficiency, fuel stability, energy content and more. | Read More

As OPG looks to co-firing or 100% biomass as some plants, Ontario must open its borders to pellets from the rest of Canada and elsewhere.

Ontario depends on exports. In fact, exports are so important to the province that it has a government agency, Ontario Exports, dedicated to “Selling Ontario to the World”. According to Ontario Exports, the province exported $126-billion worth of manufactured goods in 2009.  Without exports, Ontario wouldn’t have an economy.  That is why it is so difficult to understand its protectionist policy banning wood pellet imports for use by Ontario Power Generation (OPG), a provincial Crown corporation.

OPG is planning to re-power its Atikokan Generating Station by replacing coal with biomass and has chosen wood pellets as the preferred fuel. In early 2009, OPG issued a request for indicative prices for 90,000 tonnes/year of dry wood pellets. But there was a catch. The pellets must be Ontario sourced and processed. No pellets are allowed from other Canadian provinces or foreign suppliers.

Many people are unaware that Canada has had an Internal Trade Agreement (ITA) since 1995.  The ITA was signed by all provinces and is intended to promote an open, efficient, and stable domestic market for long-term job creation, economic growth, and stability.  All provincial governments and Crown corporations are bound by the ITA.

According to Industry Canada (www.ic.gc.ca), some key provisions of the ITA state that governments:

  • Must ensure their policies and practices do not create obstacles to trade;
  • Are not permitted to discriminate against suppliers of another province through means such as local price preferences, biasing technical specification or importing, unfair registration requirement, or unreasonable time constraints;
  • Are prohibited from using policies that favour local suppliers of goods, services, and construction;
  • Cannot restrict bids to in-province firms or direct contracts to local suppliers;
  • Are restricted from using local content, purchasing, and sourcing requirements;
  • Are prohibited from introducing new trade barriers relating to the processing of forestry (e.g., wood pellets), fisheries, and mineral resources.

Evidence is showing that Ontario is failing to meet its ITA commitments. In May 2009, the province adopted a new Green Energy Act to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in the electricity sector and create jobs in emerging technologies.  Under the Green Energy Act, developers must buy goods and services from local suppliers to qualify for feed-in tariffs.  The provincial government says this will create manufacturing jobs in Ontario, but it is a clear example of protectionist trade policy. Consequently, Japan, the United States, and the European Union have joined in a complaint to the World Trade Organization (WTO), saying that Ontario’s Green Energy Act and its local procurement requirements are a prohibited subsidy and violate international trade agreements.  Under WTO rules, the complaint could lead to trade sanctions against Canada.

Currently, Canada and the EU are negotiating a comprehensive trade agreement. This type of protectionist policy weakens Canada’s bargaining position.  How will Canada justify Ontario’s trade barriers while simultaneously arguing for improved access for Canadian products into Europe?  It is not inconceivable that in retaliation, the EU, which is Canada’s largest market for wood pellet exports, could impose restrictions on imports of Canadian wood pellets and thereby devastate the nation’s wood pellet industry.

Remember the “Buy American” policy of 2009 in which U.S. Congress insisted that only Americans were eligible to bid on projects under the American Stimulus Plan?  An outraged Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty called on Ontario municipal governments to fight this U.S. protectionism alongside the federal government.  Now, a year later, McGuinty has implemented the very type of policy he was protesting.

One of the reasons for Canadian Confederation in 1867 was cancellation by the United States of the Canadian-American Reciprocity Treaty, which allowed products into the United States free of taxes or tariffs.  Canada’s founders intended for Confederation to open unrestricted markets within Canada.  A national railway was built to facilitate this unrestricted trade.  Now, Ontario has re-implemented the protectionism that Canada was supposed to have overcome a century and a half ago.

Protectionism leads to inefficiency because suppliers do not have to face competition.  This results in higher costs to consumers.  Ontario’s green energy industry, including its wood pellet industry, will never be competitive if it is not required to face open competition. It is time for Ontario to end its export hypocrisy and harmful protectionism.


Originally published in Canadian Biomass - All rights reserved. Gordon Murray is executive director of the Wood Pellet Association of Canada (www.pellet.org) and can be reached at 250-837-8821 or This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it .

 

Industry Links

Industry Links

Markets

Markets

Become a Member

Become a Member

Safety

WPAC Safety Committee

The Board of Directors has appointed the Safety Committee to manage the safety objectives of the Wood Pellet Association of Canada ("WPAC"). The Safety Committee works in close cooperation with the BC Forest Safety Council.

Read more...
t

Power Generation

t

Sustainable power

The vast majority of Canadian wood pellets are made from sawmill residuals - sawdust. The rest are made from the residuals from harvesting operations for sawmills and pulp mills, or low-grade timber from forest industry harvest sites that has no other economic value. Think firewood. Read more...

Breathing easier - pellet emissions vs coal

Sustainability should be top of mind for any company that wants to stay in the game in today’s world.

As important a role as Greenhouse Gas (GHG) emissions play, we also need to focus on noxious emissions versus coal.

Read more...

Industry News

t

  • Pinnacle announces new off-take contract in Japan

    Pinnacle Renewable Energy today announced that it has entered…

    Read more...
  • Drax strengthens biomass sustainability policy, appoints advisory board

    Drax has strengthened its biomass sustainability policy and set…

    Read more...

The Pellet Advantage

Efficient and Plentiful Production

Wood Pellet Association of Canada members are world leaders in the design and operation of modern pellet plants.

Read more...

Innovating our way to a safer, better product

Wood pellets are a safe, reliable modern fuel. But they are still a fuel, requiring care in producing, shipping and storing.

Read more...

Renewable and sustainable? Energy really can grow on trees.

There is no single energy source capable of solving our dependence on fossil fuels. Instead we need to look to a mix of new fuels, including wood pellets.

Read more...

Argus Wood Pellet Index

US$ per metric tonneArgus Wood Pellet Index

We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website. By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. To find out more, read our Privacy Policy.